By Joao Cunha
After that surreal final in Kiev I spent the next few days wondering where this Real Madrid side ranks in the history of the game. This was not an easy task, as this season Real looked like an average team finishing 17 points behind La Liga winners Barcelona. Not only that their journey to this Champions League title was unlikely. Real escaped blowing a 3-0 lead at home when Michael Oliver made the biggest decision of his career and awarded Real a controversial penalty. (Which in my view was the correct call) Cristiano Ronaldo converted the penalty and sent Real into the semi-finals. The semi-final against Bayern was defined by two horrendous mistakes. In the first leg Rafinha gave away the ball and Lucas and Asensio played a one-two and Asensio finished off the move off with a goal. Real won the game 2-1 and proceeded to draw the second leg 2-2 to win the tie. But the second goal was due to a grave mistake by Bayern keeper Ulreich who slipped and gifted Karim Benzema an open goal. In the final Real were also a bit fortunate as Liverpool’s best player Mohamed Salah went off with an injury after a controversial challenge with Ramos. Loris Karius then gifted Benzema a goal with a terrible mistake, Mane leveled the scores at 1-1. But than Gareth Bale scored a bicycle kick for the ages and sealed the game with a 40 yard shot that Karius allowed to go through his hands. Karius had made 2 horrendous errors and Real won the final 3-1. At this point the critics were out in force questioning how good of a side Real were.
After all in this run of 4 Champions League titles in 5 years they had one La Liga title. League is the mark of consistency and Real aren’t consistent enough, which is a fair point. Real got lucky to win this edition as teams gifted them these goals, and the teams didn’t take advantage of Real’s mistakes. Real can only win big games by being unimpressive and style matters in these debates. Other great sides like Sachhi’s Milan, Herrera’s Inter, Beckenbauer’s Bayern, Cryuff’s Ajax, Pep’s Barca, or Di Stefano’s Madrid were either more consistent or played much better football.
But I think the critics of Real Madrid don’t realize how difficult this achievement is and they overrate these other great teams. Real Madrid whether some like it or not have defined an era football they are the team of this decade and they deserve to be honored as such. But let me first try to show what these other sides accomplished.
Bayern Munich 1974-76: Trophies won 1 Bundesliga, 3 European Cups, 1 Intercontinental cup.
Bayern only won 1 league title in their 3 European Cup winning runs which is the same as Real Madrid’s run. They didn’t win a domestic cup in this run either. They won the final in 1974 after a replay after a late equalizer by Schwarzbeck against Atletico denied the Spanish side the trophy. The next two finals they beat Leeds United and Saint-Ettiene 1-0 being outplayed by both sides. In 1976 they finished 10th place in the German League!!!!!
Herrera’s Inter 1963-1967: Trophies won 2 scudettos, 2 European Cups, 2 Intercontinental Cups.
La Grande Inter reached 3 European Cup finals in 4 years and really mastered catennacio under the wizard Helenio Herrera. However the second triumph is marred by allegations of Inter buying refs in the second-leg against Liverpool in 1965. They narrowly beat Benfica 1-0 in the final and were criticized for the ultra-defensive style. They lost the 1966 semi-final to Real Madrid and lost to underdogs Celtic in the 1967 final 2-1. They didn’t dominate domestically only winning 2 of 4 league titles and never winning the Italian Cup.
Sacchi’s Milan 1987-1991: Trophies won 1 Scudetto, 1 Supercoppa, 2 European Cups, 2 UEFA Super Cups, 2 Intercontinental Cup.
The standard bearer of the greatest team post-Ajax. A side that has been venerated by experts and historians for years. They dominated Europe for 2 years but only one 1 League title in Sachhi’s peak. Yet they are never judged on that for some reason. Even though Inter, Napoli, and Sampdoria all won the league in Milan’s golden era, they are given a break. Milan although dominant never won a domestic cup. Their second European cup win they barely got past Bayern in the semis winning on away goals after extra-time and narrowly edging Benfica in a tepid final 1-0. In addition the Heysel Ban prevented English clubs from competing in the European Cup until 1991 so it gave Milan a massive advantage that other clubs didn’t have. Until 1985 English clubs dominated European football so the ban made Milan’s run to the 2 straight titles easier. But they were so much better than this Real side…
Cryuff’s Ajax 1971-1973: Trophies won 2 Eredvise titles, 2 Dutch Cups, 3 European Cups, 1 Intercontinental Cup.
This Ajax fills every box possible as all-time great side, they dominated domestically winning 2 league and cups in their European Cup run. With Cryuff, Neskenns and co they tore apart many great European sides. They won 2 of their 3 finals by 2 goals, they beat the likes of Inter, Juventus, Real en route to their three-peat. They won a treble as well, This team might actually be underrated as the Dutch league was good in the 1970’s as their rivals Feyernoord won the European Cup in 1970. However the early 1970’s didn’t have many clubs who were great so Ajax were able to exploit a relatively weak era in European football. (If you don’t believe me Pananthikos got to a European Cup final in 1971 and lost to Ajax 2-0.)
Pep’s Barcelona 2008-2012: Trophies won 3 La Ligas, 2 Copa Del Rey’s, 3 Supercopa de Espana titles, 2 UEFA Champions Leagues, 2 UEFA Super Cups, 2 Club World Cups.
This team also had it all, they won a treble, a double and dominated the league. But their Champions League dominance was overstated they won the tournament 2 times in 3 years. Which is nice but Real in the 1990’s and early 2000’s did the same thing and they aren’t on this list. They needed a horrendous day by referee in the Chelsea-Barca semi in 2009 just to reach the final. They benefited from calls against Arsenal, Real en route to their 2011 title. They lost to Inter in a CL semi in 2010 and to an average Chelsea side in 2012. They did outclass Manchester United in 2 finals beating them 2-0 and 3-1. They played fantastic football and won 14 trophies but didn’t dominate Europe like other all-time sides.
Di Stefano’s Real Madrid 1955-1960: 2 La Ligas, 5 European Cups, 1 Intercontinental Cup.
Arguably the greatest club side ever this Real team won 5 straight European Cups winning finals by 2 or more goals 3 times. They beat Eintracht Frankfurt 7-3 in 1960 to seal this era of dominance with Puskas and Di Stefano scoring all 7 goals, Puskas scored 4 and Di Stefano 3. However even this team didn’t dominate domestically winning 2 out of 5 league titles which is the same as Barcelona at the time. They didn’t win the domestic cup as well. Yet this team is widely hailed as the greatest club side ever.
These comparisons needed to be shown because almost all of these great sides had luck, weak points, or circumstances that benefited them. Yet when this Real side of the last 5 years is compared they are always nitpicked for not winning enough domestically. Yet they are the most dominant European side since Di Stefano’s Real. That is a fact. They have won every available trophy since 2013-14, 13 trophies in total.
Modern day Real Madrid 2013-2018: 1 La Liga, 1 Copa Del Rey, 1 Supercopa de Espana, 4 Champions Leagues, 3 UEFA Super Cups, 3 Club World Cups.
That’s dominance 13 titles in 5 years, only Pep’s Barca had more trophies. But even that side won half as many Champions Leagues. They didn’t win the league as much but they finished 3 points, 2 points, 1 point away from the league winners in 2014, 2015 and 2016. They did win the league and Champions League double in 2017. Real have won 3 CL finals by 2 or more goals, 2 finals by 3 goals against Atletico in 2014 and Juventus in 2017. Since 2013 they haven’t lost a one-off final winning 11 straight finals, beating Barcelona, Atletico Madrid (twice), Sevilla (twice), Gremio, San Lorenzo, Kashima Antlers, Juventus, Manchester United, and Liverpool. Since 2013 Real have been one of the greatest away sides ever winning at Liverpool, Barcelona (twice), Atletico Madrid (twice), Sevilla, Napoli, Roma, Juventus, Paris Saint Germain, Dortmund, Schalke (twice), Galatasray, and Bayern Munich (three times!). They have won Champions League ties 9-2, 5-0, 4-0, 6-2, 6-3, 4-2, and 5-2 on aggregate since 2013-14. They are a ruthless team taking advantage of any mistake the opponent makes, teams have bad mistakes not just due to bad luck. It was also due to the pressure of playing Real Madrid in big games, no side had their experience and winning mentality. That caused mistakes by players they wouldn’t normally make, like Atleti not marking Sergio Ramos in the 2014 final, Juventus’s mix-up that led Ronaldo’s bicycle kick, Rafinha’s bad pass, and Ulreich and Karius making terrible errors in goal. These aren’t coincidences these are players and teams pressed into errors by Real’s relentless pressure. This Real side is the team that has defined the 2010’s and the only reasons they aren’t being lauded now is due to style and time. Their style isn’t flashy, the team’s strength is mental fortitude and adaptability, Real can play various formations 4-3-3, 4-4-2, 4-3-1-2, 4-2-2-2 and be really successful with them. They have an impressive ability of never getting rattled no matter how much they are getting outplayed, the Bayern Munich semi-final this year is proof of this. Real also have great individual players who work really hard. The core group of Navas, Carvajal, Ramos, Varance, Marcelo, Kroos, Modric, Casemiro, Isco, Benzema, and Ronaldo started 2 straight Champions League finals in 2017 and 2018, Yet they have been supplemented by other great players. Di Maria was the man of the match in the 2014 final, Khedira and Xabi Alonso, Iker Casillas were vital members of that side. Contreao was a important member of the 2014 side and was in the squad in 2017 as well. Nacho, Lucas Vasquez, Asensio, Kovacic, Theo Hernandez has given Real great depth this season and the first four over several seasons. Lucas scored the first penalty in the shootout against Atletico in the 2016 CL final, Asensio scored the 4th goal in the 2017 final. Pepe and Morata were important members of the team as well, Pepe starting the 2016 final and being the starter in the 2014 edition until the final. Morata was part of the squad that won the CL in 2014 and 2017. James Rodriguez was a crucial member when Real won the league in 2017 and was a squad player in the 2016 and 2017 wins. Gareth Bale who has been reduced to a bench role this season scored the winning the goal in the 2014 final as a starter, assisted Ramos’s goal in the 2016 final as a starter. As a sub in the final against Liverpool he was the best player on the pitch and scored a decisive brace. Real’s strength in depth makes this side unique they have 16-17 players capable of deciding a match or being the best player at any given match. That is something that sets them apart from other great sides.
I mentioned time as another reason why people devalue Real’s achievement because Real made it look easier than it is. They aren’t flashy so some people think a side can do this again soon, and they will be sorely mistaken. This kind of run has happened once since the Real side of 1955-1960, this current Real team are the closest equivalent to that side winning 4 of the last 5 Champions League titles and reaching the semis 8 straight seasons. In 10-20 years time even the most vocal critics of this side will say how the hell did a team win 4 out of 5 Champions Leagues??? Why did we not see at the time how great of a side this was? Because a lot of people have historical amnesia they think the past everything was much better than it was, and the present is much worse than it is. This Real Madrid team is much better than it is being portrayed and all other great sides are all a bit overrated through the erasing of their difficulties and luck. Real more than any other side has defined its generation by winning, over and over again. Sid Lowe in his prediction of the Champions League on ESPN picked Real to win 3-1 and gave a great quote why Real would win. He explained that when, “Madrid play well, they beat you. They play average, they beat you. The play badly, they beat you.” That sums Real up perfectly they just win. 5 years ago Madridistas used to obsess over La Decima, the tenth Champions League. Now they have lost count and are dreaming about a 14th Champions League next. Some teams may have more style, more domestic dominance, more explainable wins, less luck, but almost all of them don’t win this much. This Real Madrid is one of a kind and maybe not now but in 10 years they will be the side that is most remembered in the 2010’s.